The Other Son

This is the d’var Torah I delivered at Congregation Neveh Shalom on Friday, November 13, 2026.


There’s a beautiful and poignant song by Maddie Zahm that I highly recommend you search for after Shabbat. It’s called “Mothers and Daughters,” and she sings it from the perspective of a daughter, realizing she’s becoming her mother.

Sometimes I hear myself say something to my children and realize halfway through the sentence that I sound exactly like Cindy Posen. Sometimes I’m grateful. And sometimes I understand, with remarkable clarity, why my children are rolling their eyes. And sometimes I wonder what else I’ve learned from the adults who raised me that I only notice when I hear it coming out of my own mouth.

In Parshat Toldot, Isaac and Rebecca raise two sons. The Torah tells us plainly that Isaac loves Esau and Rebecca loves Jacob. When Isaac grows old, Rebecca helps Jacob disguise himself as his brother and receive the blessing Isaac intended for Esau. When Esau discovers what has happened, he cries out, “Have you only one blessing, Father?” (Genesis 27:38)

I wonder what Isaac hears in that cry. Years earlier, his own father faced a demand to choose between his sons. Sarah insists that Abraham send Hagar and Ishmael away so that Ishmael will have no share in Isaac’s inheritance. The Torah tells us this grieves Abraham because Ishmael is his son. God promises that Ishmael, too, will become a nation. And still, in the morning, Abraham sends him away. Isaac grows up as the son who stays. Now he hears what it sounds like to be the other son.

There’s another story about Isaac in this parshah. He digs out Abraham’s wells and calls them by the names his father gave them. Isaac knows exactly what he’s preserving when he restores those wells. I wonder how much harder it is to recognize what we’re carrying forward when it’s a way of loving our children. What did Isaac learn about what a father owes each of his sons? Did he ever have a chance to ask?

Esau’s question, “Have you only one blessing, Father?” stays with me because children are so often the first to say aloud what the adults in a family have learned to live with. They notice who gets forgiven, who is expected to be the easy one, and whose hurt everyone has learned to explain away. Sometimes they ask us about it at the very moment we’re sure we’ve been fair.

This Shabbat, think of a story your family tells about the way things have always been. Ask someone from another generation how they remember it. Listen especially for the person whose version you rarely hear. There may be a blessing you’ve been waiting for from the generation before you. There may also be one that someone is still waiting to hear from you.

Already Torn

This is the d’var Torah I delivered at Congregation Neveh Shalom on Saturday, November 7, 2026.


There are moments when I wish my heart would pick a lane. Grateful or grieving. Hopeful or afraid. Certain of what I believe or willing to hear something that unsettles me. It would make answering “How are you?” considerably easier. Instead, we carry feelings that seem to pull in opposite directions, wondering whether being torn means we have somehow lost our way. I know this has been a familiar feeling for many of us this week, in fact.

Parshat Chayei Sarah begins with Sarah’s death. Abraham must find a place to bury the woman with whom he built a life. He approaches the local inhabitants with a striking description of himself: “Ger v’toshav anochi imachem.” “I am a stranger and a resident among you.” (Genesis 23:4) The portion then follows the search for a wife for Isaac, Rebekah’s courageous departure from home, and eventually Abraham’s death.

But I keep returning to Abraham’s introduction. A stranger AND a resident? Which is it? Does he belong, or doesn’t he?

Perhaps Abraham’s words name something we recognize. We can belong somewhere and still feel alienated within it. We can love a community and struggle with its choices. We can hold convictions deeply and feel uncertain about how to live them faithfully. Abraham stands before his neighbors carrying both belonging and distance. And from that complicated place, he asks for what he needs. He does not wait until his heart is settled to take the next necessary step.

Later, Isaac brings Rebekah into Sarah’s tent, loves her, and finds comfort after his mother’s death. (Genesis 24:67) The Torah gives us no reason to imagine that love erases his grief. Instead, the tent that held absence makes room for relationship again.

Our text explains what it means to feel torn. We can ask what faithfulness requires of us today, even when we cannot resolve everything we feel. We can reach for someone without having the perfect words. We can make room for joy without betraying our sorrow.

This Shabbat, resist the pressure to offer a tidy account of our hearts. Instead, tell someone you trust where you’re struggling. Let us listen when another person shares a tension we can’t ease. And let us choose one act that gives our deepest values a place to live.

Abraham secures a burial place. Isaac opens a tent to love. Neither can restore the world they knew, but both help make a future possible. May we find courage to do the same.

Shabbat shalom.

Fear Factor

This is the d’var Torah I delivered at Congregation Neveh Shalom on Saturday, October 24, 2026.


Most of us have said something out of fear that we would never have said otherwise. We leave out a detail. Shift responsibility. Tell ourselves that a small dishonesty will prevent a bigger problem. Fear has a remarkable ability to make a questionable choice sound perfectly reasonable, especially when we are the ones who stand to benefit.

In Parshat Lech Lecha, God calls Avram to leave his homeland and journey toward an unknown future. Avram goes, bringing Sarai and their household with him. He builds altars and follows God’s promise. But then famine forces them toward Egypt, and the man who courageously left everything familiar becomes frightened of what strangers might do.

Now, for the first time, the Torah lets us hear him speak. His first recorded speech is to Sarai. He fears the Egyptians will kill him because they desire her. His solution? Ask her to say she is his sister, “that my life may be spared because of you.” (Genesis 12:13)

Our introduction to Avram’s voice is a request that his wife conceal their marriage to protect him. What happens to the promise of becoming a blessing when fear makes our own survival the only thing we can see?

Ramban refuses to excuse Avram. Commenting on Genesis 12:10, he calls Avram’s decision a serious sin, committed unintentionally, because his fear for himself placed his righteous wife in danger. The ancestor of our people is accountable for the harm his fear produces.

That’s an uncomfortable, necessary teaching. Fear can be understandable, and our response can still be wrong. We can deserve compassion and owe someone an apology. Being afraid does not relieve us of responsibility for whom we put at risk.

Perhaps this is why Torah lets us hear these words. We need ancestors whose struggles help us recognize our own. The same person can answer God’s call with courage and, moments later, ask someone else to carry the cost of his fear.

This week, when fear begins writing our script, let us pause before speaking. Whose safety have I considered? Whose voice have I left out? Am I asking someone else to bear what I am unwilling to face? Lech Lecha asks us to move forward. May we take that next step with enough courage to tell the truth and enough care to notice who walks beside us.

Trust Fall

This is the d’var Torah I delivered at Congregation Neveh Shalom on Saturday, October 24, 2026.


Trust is one of those things we rarely notice until it breaks. We trust the GPS to get us there, and the surgeon to know what she’s doing. Sometimes we trust the group chat with information we absolutely should not. But the trust that shapes our lives is quieter. In whom do we confide? To whom do we hand our hopes? Whom do we let in, knowing they could let us down?

This week, in Parshat Lech Lecha, Abram makes the biggest trust decision in Jewish history. God says, “Lech lecha.” Go from your land, your birthplace, your father’s house, to a place I will show you. With no map and no itinerary, Abram goes. Along the way, famine sends him to Egypt, where fear takes over. He asks Sarai to say she is his sister, so that Pharaoh won’t kill him. Later, God promises descendants as numerous as the stars, and Abram asks, “How will I know?”

Here’s what strikes me: the man who trusted God enough to leave everything is the same man who didn’t trust God enough to protect him in Egypt. The Ramban is blunt about it, saying Abram sinned by not trusting that God would save him and Sarai. Yet the Torah also says of Abram, “V’he’emin baShem.” He believed in God, and God counted it as righteousness.”

So, which is it? I think the Torah is telling us that trust is not a personality trait. It’s a choice we make again and again, and we don’t make it perfectly. Notice that when Abram asks “How will I know?” God doesn’t rebuke him. God answers with a covenant. Trust, it turns out, does not mean the absence of questions. Healthy trust has room to ask.

Rashi reads “lech lecha” as “go for yourself,” for your own benefit. Maybe that’s the point. Trusting others, when we do it wisely, is how we become more fully ourselves. And protecting ourselves out of fear, as Abram did in Egypt, often costs us the very relationships we’re trying to guard.

So this week, consider two questions. First, where is fear making my choices for me? And second, who in my life has earned a leap of faith?

Trust the people who have shown up. Ask your questions out loud. Be honest when you’re afraid. And when you do take the leap, know that no one gets it right every time, not even Abraham.

Lech lecha. Take the step and go. And may we find people worthy of walking beside us.

Shabbat shalom.

Cribs: Torah Edition

This is the d’var Torah I delivered at Congregation Neveh Shalom on Friday, October 16, 2026. It’s dedicated to Shiri and Matan, the carriers – and great question-askers – of so much Torah.

Do you know this song? “Rise and shine, and sing out your glory, glory.” My mom used to sing it to me whenever we arrived at this week’s Torah portion, and I can’t help hearing it in my head every year. Noah’s ark! Animals! A rainbow! It all seems innocent enough.

I also think back to when Duncan and I picked out bedding for Shiri. We wanted something gentle and something that wasn’t stereotypically gendered. We chose Noah’s ark, complete with happy animals nestled together. Little did we know how much significance that Torah story would eventually hold for our family.

But here’s the thing about Parshat Noach: it isn’t exactly a cheerful children’s story, despite the number of PJ Library books dedicated to it. Have you read it? The world is in shambles. People are cruel to one another. God is angry. There is destruction, death, and, even after the flood, some deeply troubling family dynamics. This is a questionable choice for a calming nursery theme.

It is, however, a powerful story for becoming a parent.

When Shiri was two, Duncan and I began a project called “Parenting by the Parshah.” Each week, we recorded a video exploring a parenting lesson from the Torah portion. For Noach, I remembered a day from those first exhausting weeks of parenthood.

Shiri was a month or two old, and wouldn’t stop screaming. I tried everything I could think of. Nothing worked. Finally, I reached the point where I could feel my own frustration taking over. With Shiri safe in the crib, I walked into our bedroom and did my own screaming and crying.

I needed somewhere to put all the feelings I couldn’t fix.

That experience changed how I read the story of the ark. God sees a world filled with violence and responds with apocalyptic destruction. In the parenting lens I brought to the text, the flood looked like a cosmic eruption of frustration. But there was a place of safety, a place of protection amid the storm. The ark was the crib.

This is not a perfect comparison. Just to be clear, an infant’s crying is not wrongdoing, and wiping out humanity probably isn’t the best model for how parents should handle their frustration, tempting as it might be. The part that spoke to me was the need for a safe place when emotions become too big to hold. It was the crib for Shiri. It was my room for me. It was the ark for Noah.

And this will come as no surprise to parents: the flood isn’t the last time God is frustrated. It’s not even the last time God is frustrated in this one Torah portion. Parshat Noah doesn’t end with the happy rainbow. Instead, humanity builds the Tower of Babel. God does stay true to the covenant of not destroying the world again, but there are consequences nonetheless. God confuses their language and scatters them. But the world survives.

Reading these episodes together, I hear a question for every parent—and every human being. Obviously, frustration will rise again, and when it does, can our response change? Can we keep the promises we made when we were calm?

Everyone has moments when you can’t quiet the crying, solve the problem, or make another person understand. But what you can do is protect the people in your care, recognize your limits, and create enough space to choose what happens next.

So this week, do a little check for yourself. Do you have an ark ready before the emotional waters rise? Do you know when to pause? Whom to call? Will you give yourself permission to say, “I need a moment,” and make room for someone else to say it, too? Then, when the waters recede, return. Return to the conversation, to the child, to the work of repairing whatever needs our care.

The ark – the protective pause – is the most important character in the story because of what it makes possible afterward. May our own protective pauses lead to gentler voices, wiser choices, and renewed promises.

This, too, is Torah.